For those of you who do not already know, CJ runs 2 leagues with way more rules than we have here, GM Football League and GM Football League II. There is no way this was intentional and in my mind, that goes a long way in deciding what to do.
The punishment for an intentional violation is the loss of your team, and that is off the table in this case. I never set up punishments for unintentional violations, perhaps I should have. I didn't, so here we are.
I used the draft pick thing in the poll because CJ brought it up in his apology post, and that's what he uses in GM League for repeated roster violations.
I have my opinions on this case and I just want to hear from the league about their opinions.