New York (NY) Stars sends:
1977 Round 4 Selection 25
1977 Round 5 Selection 25

Georgia Force sends:
1979 Round 3 (Georgia)


(This is an automated message. If you believe this trade warrants additional investigation, please contact the league admin.)

Please review this trade

Reason I am asking
Gain/Loss %
Trader A (NY Stars): +60.98%
Trader B (Force): -37.88%

A projected mid 3rd is worth more than a late 4th and 5th

I will run this past the trade committee. The advantage for Georgia is getting to use these picks now, while I am deferring mine for two years.

Georgia was 15-1 and 12-4 the last two seasons, so the 1979 No. 3 is likely to be a late pick as well.

No offense Commish. Just asking for it to be reviewed by more experienced owners because, in my opinion, I believe it to be too lenient to one way

No prob. I have sent it to the other two committee members as well as an alternate.

I have seen this trade occur in other leagues a few times. Now personally I do not like this trade.

What I do not like about this trade is that New York Owner will be here in two season (He is the commissioner) the owner of the Georgia team may not and the new owner will suffer from a trade he did not make.

I didn't check who the owner of the Dallas team. Let me see who it is.

After looking over all my concerns about this trade.

Taking my personal feelings about these types of deal out.

I would approve this trade

The trade committee votes, 3-0, to approve this trade.

Having said that, I made my initial offer without really looking at the trade meter. When I did, I realize the deal looks uneven from that perspective. I sent a PM to dangitdarnit offering to void the trade and rework it to make the totals match more closely. He thanked me, but declined. If he is ever in need, I will remember I owe him one, or at least part of one.

And I made frienememies by asking for a review.