setherick wrote:
I looked at the stats in MFN 1 recently, and we don't want 4.6. There was one QB with >60% completion, and there was a CB that had 50 knockdowns and the season isn't over yet. I don't know what happened in beta, but it's not good.
but we want stats from 4.5? thousands of games played and unlimited user plans resulted in pretty horrible stats as well. most that were seen in beta, complained about but released anyway.
There would be no difference if it were released. People would complain and then figure out how to make the stats fit, but here are some that havent changed or got worse under 4.5
1. is the supposed 8 punt blocks in one game. hey but it happened in highschool once so why not here. we use equivalent 40 times so why not have similar stats.
2. Low accuracy qbs cant even complete a pass. no explination needed
3. zero qb runs.......
4. speed clearly rules or slow skill players are at a clear disadvantage
5. Over half of all passes go in to tight coverage
6. i had a seasons worth of tackle for losses in one game by one guy
7. a general lack of broken tackles by high breaktackle players...on the other side high tackling doesnt matter
8. A true wr can play db and pick off an absurd amount of passes and take them back for tds
9. Zone is severly broke in terms of effectiveness compared to a man under scheme
10. sacks are generally low same with hurries.....and knock downs and drops are broke there too!
could go on and on but you in particular have been the single most advocate for 4.5. only cause you had a hand in the testing. Your absence of the development of 4.6 is the only reason for a comment about it not being good
i am not advocating 4.6 as it clearly has some of the same flaws as 4.5 but its definitely better than 4.5. because its different in some areas .
countless man hours went into the final product of 4.5 when a dozen tweaks have been made to 4.6 . with only 600 games that have been tested by maybe 50 users different plans.
but none of it matters cause if it wasnt relased months ago....why would it be now?
i like any version but i am clearly over 4.5s poor stats.